New York - Greenwich Village

Delicious ice cream. Really good coffee also. I tried the pistachio latte and it was creamy, and sweet but not overbearingly so. The sweetness and pistachio flavor were subtle. The interior is quite nice, dim and cozy vibes. Not a whole lot seating which is fine. The staff were young girls, either high school or college age and they weren't very warm or welcoming. You can order your ice cream via a kiosk system but still need to give the front of house staff the ticket? I guess they don't have a ticket machine where they get the guest's orders? It was weird. My husband and I ordered on the machine and then the girls yelled for him to give them the receipt to make the order. Asides from that strangeness, I really enjoyed my first visit here for a sweet treat during date night. I would definitely return and highly recommend others to try them out!

Beautiful, decadent, silky, throat-melting, rich & cosy, thick & creamy, NYC-style hot chocolate. It wasn’t too sweet, and had a natural, perfect balance of cocoa and milk. The little 6 $ cup went a long way. You can also ask for whipped cream on top!

They have SO many hot chocolate options, I chose the thicket Italian style one with almond. It was actually so good and very worth the price in New York. I appreciate that I can customize it. Also there is lots of seating and it’s clean and nice

I tried gelato for the first time today and it was really good! It’s definitely a little pricey but still a good bucket list place. They also sell drinks and macarons (and they have Wi-Fi) so it’s a great study spot too.

Maya and L were absolutely instrumental in creating a delightful experience at the Tasty Gelato Shop. From the moment customers walked in, their warm smiles and friendly greetings set a welcoming tone that made everyone feel at home. Maya, with her extensive knowledge of gelato flavors and ingredients, was always ready to offer recommendations tailored to individual tastes. Whether a customer was seeking something fruity and refreshing or rich and indulgent, Maya had the perfect suggestion up her sleeve, turning each visit into a personalized treat. Meanwhile, L was the embodiment of efficiency and organization behind the counter. Their skillful hands moved quickly as they scooped the gelato, ensuring that every serving was generous and aesthetically pleasing. L’s attention to detail didn't stop at just the gelato; they also took pride in the presentation of the shop. The vibrant displays of colorful gelato, along with the meticulously arranged toppings, created an inviting atmosphere that drew customers in. L's ability to juggle multiple orders while maintaining a cheerful demeanor kept the line moving smoothly, making sure no one had to wait long for their sweet treat. Together, Maya and L not only enhanced the customer experience but also fostered a sense of community within the shop. They often engaged customers in light-hearted conversations, sharing fun facts about gelato and even offering samples of new flavors. Their genuine enthusiasm for gelato was infectious, encouraging patrons to explore and try new combinations. By the time customers left, they not only had a delicious gelato in hand but also a smile on their face, thanks to the exceptional service provided by Maya and L. Their teamwork truly exemplified what it means to create a memorable and enjoyable outing at the Tasty Gelato Shop.